Why Does a Bishop Carry a Shepherd's Crook? The Metaphor Is the Whole Point
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A tall staff curved at the top is carried by bishops in several traditions, and the shape is a deliberate reference to a job most bishops have never done.
What the object is
The staff is roughly the height of a person, usually in several sections so it can be dismantled for travel, and topped by a curve or hook. It is carried in the left hand, leaving the right free to give a blessing, and is held with the curve turned outward towards the people. It is used in procession and at particular moments in a service, and is set aside at others. Materials range from plain wood to elaborately carved ivory and precious metal, and medieval examples are among the finest surviving small sculpture.
What the shape means
Each part of the form is given a reading:
- •The hook gathers, as a shepherd draws back a straying animal
- •The straight shaft supports, as a staff supports a walker
- •The pointed base prods, representing correction
- •The curve turned outward indicates care directed at the people
- •The whole refers to the image of a pastor with a flock
- •The word pastor itself means shepherd
Where the form came from
The origin is disputed between two plausible sources and the evidence does not settle it. One account derives it from the ordinary walking staff carried by travellers in late antiquity, which a bishop would have used in practice and which acquired significance by association. The other derives it from the curved staff carried by Roman officials taking auguries, a ceremonial object of clear authority that Christian usage absorbed along with much other imperial ceremonial. Eastern traditions developed a different form entirely, with a top like a pair of serpents or a crossbar rather than a hook.
The finest surviving examples
The curved head of the staff became a field for sculpture and the survivals are exceptional objects. Medieval examples in walrus ivory and in enamelled copper carry scenes carved inside the spiral of the curve, so a complete narrative occupies a space a few centimetres across. Limoges workshops produced enamelled versions in quantity for export across Europe in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, and a substantial number survive. Irish and Scottish examples from earlier centuries were later enclosed in decorated metal shrines and kept as relics, having belonged to a founding saint, which is why several survive at all.
The rules about carrying it
Practice around the object is more regulated than its symbolism suggests. A bishop carries it within their own territory and traditionally not within another's, since it signifies jurisdiction rather than personal rank, which is why a visiting bishop may carry one only by permission. Abbots of monasteries carry one for the same reason, holding authority over their community. In some traditions an abbot's is turned inward to indicate that the authority is internal to the house. Retired bishops keep the object and the restrictions on its use change, and the details differ between denominations.
The takeaway
A staff curved at the top, carried in the left hand with the hook turned outward, refers directly to a shepherd's crook and to the pastoral image behind the word pastor. Its origin is disputed between a traveller's walking staff and a Roman augural staff. It signifies jurisdiction rather than rank, so it is carried within a bishop's own territory and not in another's.