What Is a Sketchbook? The Working Space Where Nothing Has to Succeed
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A bound book of blank pages carried and worked in continuously is a standard tool across visual disciplines. Its value comes almost entirely from the absence of an audience, which changes what a person is willing to attempt on a page.
What it is for
The function is practice, observation and thinking rather than production, and treating it as a place to make finished work defeats it. Drawing from observation trains looking, which is the skill most representational work depends on and which improves only with repetition. Ideas are developed by being tried in several forms quickly, and a page of small variations answers questions that thinking about them does not. Visual information is recorded for later use, which is what artists did before photography and what many still prefer, since drawing something requires understanding it in a way that photographing it does not. Materials are tested. Compositions are worked out before being committed to an expensive surface. The unifying feature is that all of this requires permission to produce bad work, which is exactly what a private book provides and what a surface intended for display does not.
What ends up in them
The contents of working sketchbooks are more varied than the name suggests:
- •Observational drawings of whatever was available, which is mostly hands, feet, people sitting still and objects on tables
- •Thumbnail compositions, small and fast, testing arrangements before any commitment
- •Studies of a single problem repeated, such as a fold of cloth or a particular angle of a head
- •Written notes, since visual thinking and verbal thinking interleave and separating them is artificial
- •Copies of other people's work, which is a traditional training method and remains one of the fastest ways to learn
- •Colour notes, material tests and a great deal that is simply unsuccessful
The famous ones
Surviving working books are among the most revealing documents in the history of art. Leonardo's notebooks contain anatomical study, engineering, observation of water and an enormous quantity of material that never became a painting, and they show a mind working rather than a reputation being managed. Turner's sketchbooks, preserved in large numbers, record the observation underlying paintings that look invented. Working books by many artists show compositions abandoned, figures moved and ideas tried and rejected, which contradicts the impression that finished works arrived whole. The historical value creates a modern awkwardness, since artists now know that such books may be exhibited and published, which reintroduces exactly the audience the format exists to exclude. Several have said they keep a private book alongside a presentable one, which is a reasonable response to a real problem.
The digital version
Drawing on a tablet reproduces much of the function and changes some of it in ways worth noticing. The obvious gains are undo, layers, an unlimited supply of pages, and every material available without carrying any of them, all of which lower the cost of experimenting. The losses are subtler. Undo removes the need to commit, and a mark that can be erased costlessly is made with less attention than one that cannot, which several artists report as a real difference in how carefully they look before drawing. The surface gives uniform feedback regardless of the tool selected, so the physical differences between materials are simulated rather than felt. Pages are not physically sequential, so the accumulating record that makes a paper book valuable requires deliberate organisation. Many practitioners use both, and the common pattern is paper for observation and digital for developing work towards a finished piece.
Keeping one
The practical advice from people who maintain the habit is consistent and mostly concerns removing obstacles. Choose a book small enough to carry, since the one left at home is not used. Accept that most pages will be poor, since the ratio is roughly fixed and the only way to more good pages is more pages. Do not skip pages or start again, since a continuous record shows progress that is invisible day to day. Work from life rather than from screens where possible, because the difficulty is the point. Set a low threshold, since five minutes regularly beats an hour occasionally. Date the pages. Resist the temptation to make each spread attractive, which converts the book into a performance and stops it functioning. And keep old ones, since looking back over a year of them is the clearest evidence of improvement most people ever get.
The takeaway
The value comes from having no audience, which permits the bad work that practice requires, and treating it as a place for finished pieces removes that. Observation, quick variations, recorded information and material tests are what it holds. Surviving examples show compositions abandoned and ideas rejected, which contradicts the impression that finished works arrived whole. The habit depends on a low threshold and a carried book.