How Do Plants Defend Themselves? An Arms Race Fought Standing Still
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A plant cannot run from anything eating it, which leaves chemistry, armour and recruiting allies. The results are everywhere in daily life, since a large share of the flavours, medicines, stimulants and poisons people use are compounds plants evolved to make insects and grazing animals leave them alone.
Chemical defence
Plants produce enormous numbers of secondary metabolites, meaning compounds not required for basic growth, and most of them are defensive. Alkaloids including nicotine, caffeine, morphine, quinine and strychnine are nitrogen-containing compounds that act on animal nervous systems, and their effects on humans are side effects of their function as insecticides and deterrents. Terpenes provide many of the strong scents in herbs, conifers and citrus and are both toxic and repellent. Phenolics including tannins bind proteins, making foliage hard to digest, which is why tannin-rich leaves and unripe fruit taste astringent. Some plants store defensive compounds in inactive form alongside a separate enzyme, so that damage mixes the two and generates the toxin on the spot, which is how cyanide-releasing plants and the mustard oils in brassicas work, and it is why cutting an onion or crushing garlic produces compounds that were not present in the intact tissue. Digitalis, pyrethrum and many modern insecticides are plant compounds or derivatives, so agriculture is substantially built on borrowed plant chemistry.
Physical and cooperative defences
Chemistry is only part of the repertoire, and several defences involve conscripting other organisms entirely:
- •Thorns, spines and prickles, which are modified stems, leaves and epidermal outgrowths respectively, deterring large herbivores
- •Trichomes, meaning surface hairs, which can be simply obstructive, glandular and sticky, or hooked sharply enough to injure small insects
- •Silica and calcium oxalate crystals, which wear down insect mouthparts and vertebrate teeth, and which are why grasses are abrasive and why some houseplants burn the mouth
- •Tough waxy cuticles and lignified tissue, which raise the physical cost of feeding
- •Extrafloral nectaries, which feed ants that then patrol the plant and attack herbivores, with acacias providing both food and hollow thorns as housing in a well-studied partnership
- •Volatile signals released on damage that attract predatory and parasitic insects to the herbivore attacking the plant, which is defence by calling for reinforcements
Induced defence and signalling
Much defence is not permanently maintained but switched on when needed, because producing toxins is expensive and diverting resources from growth has a cost. Damage triggers a signalling cascade, with jasmonic acid a central messenger for chewing herbivores and salicylic acid for many pathogens, leading to production of defensive compounds and proteins in the damaged tissue and in undamaged parts of the same plant, so that an attack in one place primes the whole organism. Volatile compounds released from damaged tissue travel through the air, and there is good evidence that neighbouring plants detect them and prime their own defences, which is frequently reported as plants talking to each other and is more accurately described as eavesdropping on a signal that primarily coordinates parts of the same plant. Signals also pass through fungal networks connecting root systems, though claims about the extent and function of that communication have attracted serious methodological criticism recently, and the honest position is that transfer occurs while its ecological importance remains genuinely contested.
The arms race and what humans did to it
Herbivores counter-adapt, evolving detoxification enzymes, behavioural avoidance, tolerance and in some cases the ability to store plant toxins in their own bodies for protection, which is what monarch butterflies do with milkweed compounds. That reciprocal escalation is a classic example of coevolution and explains why many insects are restricted to a narrow range of host plants, since specialising on one chemical defence makes others harder to overcome. Humans have intervened in this repeatedly. Domestication generally selected against defensive chemistry, because people preferred plants that were less bitter and less toxic, which made crops more palatable and simultaneously more vulnerable, so modern agriculture replaces the lost defences with applied pesticides. Occasional reversals occur, as when stressed plants revert to producing higher toxin levels, which is behind documented poisonings from bitter varieties. The same chemistry supplies a large share of pharmaceuticals, and screening plants for biological activity remains a productive route to new drugs precisely because those molecules were selected over millions of years to affect animal physiology.
The takeaway
Being rooted leaves chemistry, armour and allies. Alkaloids, terpenes and tannins are insecticides and deterrents whose effects on people are incidental, and some are stored inactive so that damage mixes them with an enzyme and makes the toxin on the spot. Ants are paid in nectar to patrol, and damaged plants release volatiles that attract the predators of their attackers. Domestication bred the defences out, so pesticides replace them.