What Is a Placoderm? Armoured Fish That Invented Biting
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
For most of the Devonian the seas were dominated by fish encased in bony armour plates, with jaws made of shearing bone edges rather than teeth. They include the first known animals with jaws and the first known to reproduce by internal fertilisation, and then they vanished completely.
What they were built like
A placoderm's head and the front part of its body were enclosed in interlocking plates of bone, joined by a hinge at the neck so that the head could be raised, which is unusual and allowed a very wide gape. The rear of the body was generally unarmoured and often left little fossil trace, which is why many species are known mainly from head shields. In place of teeth, the jaw bones bore sharpened edges that sheared against each other and self-sharpened through wear, and in the largest species those blades could generate bite forces comparable to the strongest measured in any animal, according to modelling of Dunkleosteus, a predator reaching several metres in length. The group occupied a wide range of roles, with flattened bottom-dwelling forms, fast open-water predators and small forms that filtered or crushed shelled prey, and they lived in marine and freshwater environments worldwide, which is why the Devonian is frequently called the age of fishes.
The firsts they document
The group supplies several of the earliest known examples of features that became universal among vertebrates:
- •Jaws, since placoderms are among the earliest jawed vertebrates and the origin of jaws from gill arch skeleton is one of the major transitions in the group's ancestry
- •Internal fertilisation and live birth, demonstrated by a specimen from Australia preserving an embryo attached by a mineralised umbilical structure, which pushed the origin of that reproductive mode back enormously
- •Claspers in males, the structures used for internal fertilisation that also appear in sharks, which raised questions about whether the feature was inherited or evolved twice
- •True teeth in some members, which bears directly on the long argument about whether teeth arose from skin denticles migrating inward or from within the mouth outward
- •Paired fins in a recognisably modern arrangement, which is the foundation of the vertebrate limb
- •Bone in the dermal skeleton, which preserves well and supplies much of what is known about early vertebrate development
Where they sit on the tree
Their position has been substantially revised and the revision matters. They were long treated as a distinct class that branched off early and left no descendants, which made them an evolutionary side road. Modern analyses, driven by newly described fossils from China in particular, indicate that placoderms are not a single natural group but a series of successive branches near the base of the jawed vertebrates, some of them closer than others to the ancestry of everything that followed. That means the features they show are not curiosities but stages in the assembly of the standard vertebrate body plan, and it makes them ancestral in a meaningful sense rather than merely early. Specimens including Entelognathus, described in 2013, carry a combination of armoured placoderm features and the jaw bones characteristic of bony fishes and therefore of land vertebrates, which connected two groups that had appeared quite separate.
The end and what replaced them
The group disappeared entirely at the end of the Devonian, in a series of extinction pulses that removed a large proportion of marine life and that are associated with widespread ocean anoxia, possibly driven by nutrient runoff following the spread of land plants and deep root systems. No placoderms survived, which is unusual for a group that had been so dominant and so diverse, and the reasons remain debated. What followed was a radiation of sharks and of bony fishes, both of which had been present alongside the placoderms and both of which went on to dominate afterwards. The comparison invites the usual question about whether the survivors were better designed or merely luckier, and the general pattern across extinctions supports the second reading more often than the first. What the placoderms left is not descendants but evidence, since their fossils document the sequence in which jaws, teeth, paired fins and internal fertilisation appeared.
The takeaway
Bony head armour hinged at the neck allowed an enormous gape, and shearing bone blades that sharpened themselves did the work of teeth, with bite forces in the largest among the strongest ever modelled. A specimen preserving an embryo with an umbilical connection pushed live birth back enormously. They are now understood as successive branches at the base of jawed vertebrates rather than a side road, and none survived the Devonian.