Why Did Rain Once Decide Cricket Matches? The Pitch Became Unplayable
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A drying pitch after rain used to turn batting into a lottery and spin bowling into a weapon, and the phrase outlived the conditions that produced it by half a century.
What the condition was
Before pitches were routinely covered, rain soaked the prepared strip of rolled earth and grass, and the sun that followed began drying it from the top down. That produced a surface that was soft and gluey underneath and crusting above, and a ball pitching on it could grip violently, stop, spit upwards or skid through low with no warning. The behaviour changed over the course of an hour as the drying progressed, so the same delivery was unpredictable in a way that no amount of skill from the batter could reliably counter.
What it did to the game
The tactical consequences were dramatic and well understood:
- •Spin bowlers became almost unplayable for a few hours
- •Scores collapsed, sometimes by whole teams inside an hour
- •Captains who won the toss gambled on the weather
- •Declaring early to bowl on it was a recognised tactic
- •A team could be trapped batting through the worst of it
- •Results turned on timing rather than on relative strength
Why it disappeared
Covering the pitch during rain became standard in first class cricket through the middle of the twentieth century, with full covering in England from 1981, and the conditions vanished almost entirely. The reasons were commercial and sporting at once, since matches decided by an accident of weather were unsatisfying for spectators and unfair on the side that happened to be batting. The change also altered what skills mattered, reducing the premium on the spin bowler who could exploit a drying surface and on the batter who could survive one, both of which had been prized specialisms.
What replaced it
Removing the weather from the equation did not remove pitch behaviour from the game, and the modern equivalents are deliberate rather than accidental. Groundstaff prepare surfaces to suit the home side, producing dry crumbling pitches where spin is wanted and grassy ones where seam movement is. A pitch deteriorates predictably over a five day match, which makes batting last a recognised disadvantage and the toss a genuine decision. Complaints about doctored surfaces are now a regular feature of international cricket, which is the same argument about fairness that covering was introduced to settle.
The phrase and where it went
The expression escaped the game and is now used by many people who have never watched a match, meaning an awkward situation that must be handled with care. It is recorded in the figurative sense from the late nineteenth century, so the transfer happened while the conditions were still common rather than afterwards. Several other cricketing terms made the same journey, including being bowled over, being stumped, having a good innings and playing with a straight bat, which together make the sport one of the largest single sources of everyday English idiom after seafaring.
The takeaway
Rain on an uncovered pitch followed by sun produced a surface soft underneath and crusting above, on which the ball gripped, stopped or skidded unpredictably as it dried. Spinners became unplayable and whole teams collapsed in an hour. Full covering, standard in England from 1981, ended the conditions, but the phrase had already passed into general English.