Why Do Scissors Work? Two Forces Sliding Past Each Other
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
Forces that push parallel to a surface rather than into it make layers slide over one another, and most structural failures in practice are this rather than pulling apart.
How it differs from pulling
A force applied perpendicular to a surface either stretches the material apart or squeezes it together, and those are the familiar cases. A force applied parallel to the surface does something else, tending to slide one layer of the material over the next without changing its length. A rectangle subjected to it deforms into a parallelogram rather than becoming longer or shorter. The distinction matters because materials are frequently much weaker in one mode than the other, and a design safe against one may fail immediately under the other.
Where it appears
The situations producing it are extremely common:
- •A bolt or rivet holding two overlapping plates together
- •A beam carrying a load anywhere other than at its supports
- •A shaft transmitting rotation, twisted along its length
- •Any adhesive joint loaded sideways rather than pulled apart
- •A fluid flowing past a surface, dragging on it
- •Scissors and punches, which cut by this mechanism alone
Why materials differ so much
The gap between a material's resistance to pulling and to sliding is where most engineering judgement lies. Metals are reasonably similar in both, because their atoms are held by bonds with no strong directionality. Wood is enormously stronger along the grain than across it, and splits easily when layers are pushed sideways. Concrete is strong in compression, weak in tension and weak against sliding, which is why reinforcement is placed diagonally as well as along a beam. Laminated materials fail by layers separating, which is the same mode again.
Why a beam fails at the supports
A loaded beam experiences this kind of loading most severely near its supports, which is counterintuitive since the largest bending happens in the middle. The reason is that the whole load must be transferred into the supports, and that transfer happens across vertical planes close to them, so the sliding force there is at its maximum while the bending is at its minimum. That is why reinforcement in a concrete beam is bunched near the ends and why holes cut through a beam for pipes must be placed near the middle rather than near the supports.
The fluid version
Liquids and gases resist sliding too, and their resistance to it is exactly what viscosity measures. A fluid in contact with a surface sticks to it, so a fluid flowing past a wall has a layer at rest against the wall and faster layers further out, with each layer dragging on its neighbour. That drag is what a swimmer or an aircraft feels as friction, what carries sediment along a riverbed, and what determines whether blood flows smoothly or in eddies. The thin region near a surface where speed changes rapidly is where most of it is concentrated.
The takeaway
A force parallel to a surface slides layers over one another and turns a rectangle into a parallelogram, which is a different mode of loading from stretching or squeezing and frequently the weaker one. Bolts, beams, shafts and adhesive joints all carry it. Wood and concrete resist it far less well than they resist compression, and viscosity is exactly a fluid's resistance to the same thing.