How Does a Pigeon Find Its Way Home? Several Systems Working Together
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A pigeon released hundreds of kilometres from its loft in unfamiliar country flies home reliably. Explaining how has occupied researchers for a century, and the answer involves several mechanisms rather than one.
The problem the bird solves
Navigation to a specific distant place requires two capabilities that are worth separating. The first is a compass, meaning a way of determining direction, which tells the bird which way is north and nothing about where it is. The second is a map, meaning a way of determining position relative to the goal, which tells it which direction home lies from wherever it has been released. A compass alone is useless if the bird does not know where it is, and the map problem is by far the harder of the two. Pigeons plainly solve both, since they orient correctly within minutes of release at sites they have never visited, and the compass is much better understood than the map.
What the evidence supports
Several mechanisms have experimental support and they appear to be used together:
- •A sun compass, corrected for time of day using an internal clock, demonstrated by shifting birds' clocks and observing predictable errors
- •A magnetic compass, used when the sun is obscured, demonstrated by attaching magnets
- •Olfactory cues, with birds deprived of smell showing impaired homing, which is the most contested finding
- •Familiar landmarks, used within the region a bird knows
- •Infrasound, very low frequency noise from terrain, proposed on the basis of unusual release site failures
- •Magnetic intensity and inclination as possible map information, which remains unproven
The clock shift experiment
One experiment demonstrates the sun compass cleanly enough to be worth describing in full. Birds are held for several days in a room with artificial lighting on a cycle shifted by a fixed number of hours relative to real daylight, which resets their internal clock. When released, they misjudge the time of day and therefore misjudge where the sun should be relative to the direction they want, and they depart on a bearing wrong by the predicted angle, about fifteen degrees for each hour of shift. The prediction follows directly from the sun's apparent motion and the observation matches it closely, which is a rare degree of quantitative confirmation in animal behaviour. Under overcast skies the same birds orient correctly, which is what established that a second compass exists.
What they were used for
The practical history of carrying messages by pigeon is longer and more recent than most people assume. The birds were used for official communication in the ancient Mediterranean and Near East, and a service linking cities operated across the medieval Islamic world with relay lofts. Financial news travelled by pigeon in nineteenth century Europe, giving a speed advantage worth a great deal before the telegraph. Military use was extensive in both world wars, with hundreds of thousands of birds kept, mobile lofts taken into the field, and messages carried from positions where radio was impossible or unsafe, and several individual birds were decorated for particular flights. The birds fly only towards home, so a message can be sent from anywhere back to the loft and not the other way, which shaped how services were organised.
What remains unsettled
The map problem has resisted a century of work and the reasons are instructive. Proposals based on smell hold that a bird learns the association between wind directions and the odours they carry while at the loft, and uses that to infer displacement, which is supported by experiments in some laboratories and has failed to replicate in others, with the disagreement persisting for decades and having a geographical pattern that itself needs explaining. Magnetic map proposals require the bird to detect small spatial variations in field strength, and the sensory mechanism has not been identified conclusively despite several candidates. Release site biases, where birds at particular locations consistently depart in the wrong direction, are documented and unexplained. The honest summary is that the compass mechanisms are well established and the map is not.
The takeaway
Navigation needs a compass giving direction and a map giving position relative to home, and the second is much harder. Shifting a bird's internal clock produces a departure error of about fifteen degrees per hour, exactly as the sun compass predicts, while overcast releases stay accurate, which established a magnetic compass too. The map mechanism remains unresolved after a century.