What Is Monotheism?
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
Monotheism is the belief that there is only one God. That sounds simple, but the boundary between monotheism and other positions turns out to be less sharp than expected, and tracing how the idea developed is one of the more interesting problems in the study of religion.
The claim, exactly
Monotheism holds that exactly one God exists, usually understood as the creator and as the only proper object of worship. It contrasts with polytheism, the belief in many gods, and with atheism, the absence of belief in any.
There are useful intermediate terms. Henotheism means worshipping one god while accepting that others exist. Monolatry means worshipping one exclusively without making claims about the others. Both describe positions that appear in the historical record and that are easy to mistake for full monotheism.
Which religions are monotheistic
The clearest cases are the three Abrahamic traditions:
- •Judaism, with the declaration that God is one at the centre of daily prayer
- •Christianity, holding one God understood as a trinity of persons
- •Islam, with the absolute oneness of God, called tawhid, as its foundation
- •Sikhism, which affirms one God without form
- •Zoroastrianism, often cited as an early monotheistic tradition
How the idea developed
Historians of religion generally see monotheism emerging gradually rather than appearing complete. Some biblical texts, read closely, seem to assume other gods exist while insisting that Israel worship only its own, which is monolatry rather than strict monotheism.
An unusual early episode occurred in Egypt under the pharaoh Akhenaten in the fourteenth century BCE, who promoted the sun disc Aten to the exclusion of other gods. The reform was abandoned after his death, and whether it influenced later traditions is debated without resolution.
The complicated cases
Some traditions resist the categories. Hinduism contains monotheistic schools that regard the many deities as aspects of one ultimate reality, alongside genuinely polytheistic practice and philosophical positions that are neither.
Christianity's doctrine of the trinity has been questioned from outside as compromising monotheism, and Christian theologians have spent many centuries formulating it precisely as one God in three persons. Buddhism sits outside the scheme altogether, since it does not centre on a creator god at all.
Why the distinction matters
The monotheism and polytheism split is a useful analytical tool but a blunt one, and scholars increasingly note that it was largely developed by monotheists describing others.
The more productive questions are usually about practice: who is worshipped, how, and with what exclusivity. Those questions tend to reveal more than sorting traditions into two boxes.
The problem of evil
Monotheism creates a specific philosophical difficulty that polytheism largely avoids. If one God is all powerful, all knowing and entirely good, the existence of serious suffering requires explanation.
Polytheistic systems can attribute misfortune to conflict between gods or to a deity's indifference. Monotheistic traditions cannot take that route, and the resulting body of argument, called theodicy, is enormous. Proposed answers include free will, moral development through hardship, and limits on what human beings can understand. None has settled the question, and it remains the strongest standing objection to classical monotheism.
The takeaway
Monotheism is the belief in exactly one God, held most clearly by the Abrahamic traditions, and the historical record suggests it developed gradually out of positions like monolatry rather than arriving fully formed.