Why Do Zebras Have Stripes? Four Theories and the Experiments That Tested Them
By the BrainSnail editorial team. How these articles are written and checked, and how to tell us when one is wrong.
A zebra is the most conspicuous animal on the African plains, a black and white animal in a brown landscape, and Darwin and Wallace argued about why in the 1870s. Since then at least eighteen explanations have been proposed. Four have been taken seriously enough to test, and in the last decade experiments with painted horses, model zebras and slowed-down video of flies have narrowed the answer to one that nobody found intuitive.
Camouflage
The oldest idea is that stripes hide the zebra: they break up its outline in long grass, or blend into the dappled shade of woodland, or make it hard to see at dusk when lions hunt. The trouble is that zebras live mostly in open grassland, stand in herds, and are noisy. In 2016 researchers measured how far away a lion or hyena could resolve zebra stripes, given what is known about their eyesight, and found that at the distances predators begin a hunt the stripes merge into grey and the zebra is as visible as any other horse-sized animal. By the time a lion can see the stripes it can also smell and hear the zebra. Camouflage is out.
Confusing the predator
The second idea is that a herd of striped animals running together is a dazzling mass in which a predator cannot pick a target or judge speed and direction, the logic behind the dazzle camouflage painted on ships in the First World War. It is a plausible idea and hard to test on lions. Experiments with people chasing striped targets on a screen found that stripes sometimes helped and sometimes hindered, and the field data are unhelpful in another way: lions kill zebras at about the rate their abundance predicts, so whatever the stripes do, they do not seem to make zebras harder to catch.
Keeping cool
The third idea is that black stripes heat up more than white ones, setting up small convection currents over the skin that cool the animal, which would explain why the most heavily striped zebras live in the hottest regions. Measurements do not support it. Thermal cameras show that a zebra's surface is no cooler than that of a uniformly coloured animal standing next to it, and water-filled barrels painted with stripes, grey, black or white heated up according to their average darkness, with no stripe bonus. Zebras do sweat more efficiently than most animals, but that is a separate adaptation.
Flies
The fourth idea, first suggested in the 1930s and largely ignored, is that stripes deter biting flies. Horseflies and tsetse flies in Africa carry diseases, including the trypanosomes that cause sleeping sickness, and they bite through hair. The evidence for this one has kept coming:
- •Sticky traps painted with stripes catch far fewer horseflies than plain black or white ones
- •Across the zebra's range, the intensity of striping tracks the abundance of biting flies better than it tracks predators, temperature or habitat
- •Horses wearing striped coats on a farm in Somerset were landed on by flies a quarter as often as the same horses wearing plain coats
- •High-speed video shows that flies approach a striped surface normally but fail to slow down in the last instant and bounce off or overshoot, as if they cannot judge the landing
- •Painting white stripes on Japanese cattle cut fly bites by half
Why flies, and why zebras
The mechanism seems to be that stripes disrupt the way a fly uses the pattern of light flowing across its eyes to control its landing, so it misjudges the surface. The question that remains is why zebras and not the antelope grazing beside them. The best guess is hair: a zebra's coat is unusually short, so a fly's mouthparts reach the skin, and the diseases flies carry are more dangerous to horses than to antelope. Zebras also happen to be the only wild horses left in fly country, so there is no stripeless control to compare.
The lesson of the zebra is partly about method. The camouflage and dazzle theories were attractive because they were easy to imagine; the fly theory was ignored for decades because it was not. The experiments that settled it were cheap and slightly ridiculous, involving painted barrels and horses in coats, and they are the reason a question argued over since Darwin now has an answer most biologists accept.
The takeaway
Of the four serious theories for zebra stripes, camouflage fails because predators cannot resolve the stripes at hunting distance, confusion has no field support, and cooling has been measured and found absent. Biting flies, the least intuitive, is backed by traps, geography, coated horses and high-speed video: flies cannot land properly on stripes, and zebras, with short coats and fly-borne diseases, are the animal that most needed the protection.